GitHub

Vorteile

Sehr gute Integrierbarkeit in verschiedenen Code-Editoren und eine schöne Übersicht auf der Weboberfläche mit den gängigsten Befehlen zur Verwaltung von Programmiercode. Die Versionierung hilft mir ursprüngliche Zustände wiederherzustellen und gibt auch eine gute Übersicht darüber, worin die Unterschiede in den jeweiligen Versionen liegen.

Nachteile

GitHub ist sehr komplex und verlangt eine gewisse Zeit zur Einarbeitung ab. Ich war relativ schnell mit der Vielzahl an Befehlen überfordert.

Vorteile

Anbindung über GitHub Desktop ist kinderleicht und für jeden verständlich.

Nachteile

Zu komplexen Aufgaben wie CI/CD oder GitHub Pages findet man kaum gute für Einsteiger geeigneten Anleitungen.

Vorteile

GitHub bietet eine einfache Bedienung und eine kostengünstige Möglichkeit, Projekte zu hosten

Nachteile

Echte Nachteile von meiner Seite aus konnte ich nicht ausmachen

Vorteile

Gute Integrationsmöglichkeiten mit anderen Tools und nur minimale Ausfallzeiten bei Upgrades.

Nachteile

Es gibt Speicherplatzbeschränkungen (die für mich aber bislang nicht relevant gewesen sind).

Vorteile

Sehr gute Möglichkeit zur Versionsverwaltung von Source-Code und anderen textbasierten Dokumenten. Einfaches Branchen und Mergen/Rebasen.

Nachteile

Standardmäßig gibt es nur ein command line interface.

Vorteile

It is a one of the best platform to store the code and allow team members to work on same project simultaneously without having conflicts.

Nachteile

As I used git hub to store my store far more there was no cons I got for it, It was very easy to learn just had little tricky to understand UI to resolve conflicts which issue was resolved in git desktop (application of git hub).

Vorteile

My favourite features of Github are:
- "issues" to track and discuss feature requests and bugs
- pull requests to propose changes and discuss them in comments by dedicated UI
- github actions for automatic deployment and continuous integration
- "Projects" form project management

Nachteile

I can't find anything that doesn't fit my current workflow and my team's one.

Vorteile

Nothing. I couldn't figure out how to use it.

Nachteile

It was very confusing - once I logged in, I could go no further

Vorteile

The collaborative tools are excellent, and version control is seamless. Its also incredibly user-friendly for both individuals and teams

Nachteile

Overall, pricing may get a little bit shady sometimes in the sense of hiding features behind enterprise plan. Sometimes its really difficult to understand whats included in the plan and whats not. And generally it disappoints in this sense, because some basic features are just blocked meaningless and you just have to upgrade

In Betracht gezogene Alternativen

Gründe für den Wechsel zu GitHub

Vorteile

The thing I like most about GitHub is its open source capabilities and also that multiple people can work on same code with the help of pull requests

Nachteile

The thing I don't like about GitHub is that it is not completely safe for important codes as it is mainly an Open source.

Vorteile

This is best version control i used till now.

Nachteile

I don't have anything to dislike in this github.

Vorteile

GitHub's intuitive interface, seamless collaboration features, and excellent version control system make it an indispensable tool for developers. The vast community and access to open-source projects are incredible bonuses.

Nachteile

There’s not much to dislike. However, some advanced features might feel overwhelming to beginners initially.

Vorteile

I like github actions marketplace and the ease of use of the platform

Nachteile

You don't have full control on PR (e.g. you can't delete them)

Vorteile

Its collaboration team help us working together on the same project which increase our productivity. For learning prospective i always prefer GitHub because of its user friendly interface.

Nachteile

For a beginner level person its steep to understand. With time he/she will understand the concepts as well.

Vorteile

Great thing about github is it simplifies the collaboration and branching with pull requests, issue tracking and its really easy to use with.
With github action we can even automate our code deployment process too and its really easy to work with and you never have to worry about those deployment processes.

Nachteile

The thing with github pull requests are they sometimes show more files changes then the actual but its rare and we can work around it , otherthan that everything is fine.

Vorteile

It's free and very easy to use; Plus it's supported practically everywhere.

Nachteile

None I've identified. Pleasantly surprised Microsoft didn't ruin it after acquiring it.

Vorteile

It works. Fast and on Mac OS, Windows and Linux. Integrated nicely into both Visual Studio Code (PC, Mac) and Visual Studio (PC).
Code compare. Merge. No problems.

Nachteile

It starts to eat disk space and 50Gbyte gone the other day. Some more integrated cleaning would be great.

Vorteile

Great for being able to debug issues where logs are limited in your provided with an error message that's a trace back branches commits easy to track down

Nachteile

Interface can be confusing there's a bit of a learning curve of as well of using github through cli

Vorteile

As a web manager with two years of experience in Indonesia's hospitality and F&B industry, I primarily use WordPress that uses JavaScript and sometimes I made my own Python scripts. GitHub's version control has been a standout feature for me. It eliminates the need for multiple file versions and allows easy rollbacks when errors occur. The collaboration features are excellent, especially when working with team members across different Indonesian cities. Additionally, the vast GitHub community and its open-source projects have been invaluable resources, offering solutions that we can adapt to our local market.

Nachteile

The initial learning curve with Git terminology and workflows was challenging, particularly for team members more versed in hospitality than coding. Onboarding took longer than anticipated. While GitHub excels for managing code, it's less intuitive for non-code assets like restaurant menu designs or hotel brochures, which are crucial in our industry. Lastly, for simple WordPress theme tweaks, GitHub can sometimes feel overly complex.

Vorteile

Github is a very good source control and version control system. Here developers can create free repositories that's make a good impression because they easily maintaining theirs code source. If someone needs they can purchase the paid packages.

Nachteile

I basically don't get any cons about github because i am using it's more then 8+ years. I think git conflicts documentation and resolve commands should also integrate with basic commands note.

Vorteile

What I appreciate most about GitHub is its robust ecosystem for collaboration and version control. As the owner of Prisma, a web development agency, the platform's intuitive interface and extensive repository management capabilities have been instrumental in streamlining our workflows. The ability to review code, manage projects, and collaborate on software development projects in real-time has significantly enhanced our productivity and quality of output. GitHub's integration with various development tools and its strong community support are invaluable for staying at the forefront of web technology trends.

Nachteile

While GitHub offers an extensive range of features, its learning curve can be steep for newcomers, particularly for those not familiar with Git commands or version control concepts. This aspect can slow down the initial adoption and integration into a team's workflow. Additionally, for private repositories and advanced features, the cost can escalate quickly for smaller agencies or individual developers, making it less accessible for those with limited budgets.

Vorteile

Copilot is amazing. Github makes repository access and version control very easy. Also love how many addons and integrations are available. PR reviews is also easier with split views. Search is also the best. It also goes through the code and often finds references and definitions of a function.

Nachteile

Sometimes the PR review view is tricky and bubbles up under a wrong name making it tougher to make sense of where the code is written if it's a large file.

Vorteile

It's great platform for app development, I have always used this for that and accessing other amazing projects.

Nachteile

Nothing so far. It's really great to use

Vorteile

The most I like about Github is Repository CRUD. I always use Github for my projects and create repository on Github and collaborate with my colleagues. It's really awesome. My working process is easy and fast due to Github.

Nachteile

The least I like about Github is Git merging. It was stuck something when I want to merge with my colleagues's branches like rebase. I can't push and pull at that time. I think it needs to fix it later.

Vorteile

The best part about github is its extensive open-source community which makes it easy to find and contribute to projects across various programming languages and frameworks.

Nachteile

Its a bit complex for begineers to learn.

Vorteile

Integration of AI if necessary, you are able to create your own websites and even add your own domain, you can have different versions of your project, you can integrate GitHub with Git, VS Code, IntelliJ IDEA and more.

Nachteile

The only think that I "don't like" is that you cannot publish private websites on GitHub, this is only possible on the paid version (GitHub pro). But if you don't have any issues publishing your project to the public, then this will not affect you.

Vorteile

They changed there UI this year and it kind of has a dark mode feature which I love also there the ease of usage especially for beginners.

Nachteile

Well for this I'll say their pricing plan, it normal but can still be reviewed for easy access to Pro features

Vorteile

You can setup a repository for your code and collaborate with other developers throughout the world. With Github I can showcase my work so that I can attract recruiters. It is a social media for developers. I can also look for open-source code to learn and contribute to.

Nachteile

There is a learning curve to setup a repository and collaborate. People may also find it difficult to navigate through the app with so many features. Integrating with external tools to enable automation also takes a lot of effort.

Vorteile

Easy to use even through other softwares like IDE for eg: VS Code, It has extentions to easily manage and manupulate data in my repo effortlessly

Nachteile

As of now i haven't had anything which i dont like in github

Vorteile

Github is most popular Version Control Tool. So there are plenty of content available to get started & use it. Most of open source project are on github. It's completely free so anyone can use. You can use github for open source contributions also.

Nachteile

Github cahnged the authentication mechanism to commit using only tokens not from the passwords, so a new user might face difficulties.
There's not much regulation in the github which might can be used for wrongful purpose. The CI/CD as github action needs more updates, also due complex yaml syntax it can be difficult to use.

Vorteile

Lot of features, really nice UI & UX, lots of integrations which provide lot of value. CI&CD - Github actions is really great, project management inside Github repository.
For smaller projects the pricing is friendly. And I would say its user friendly.

Nachteile

Pricing is really big con for bigger organizations, cloud gets expensive here, and I am not even mentioning premium features. Github project management is really simple here, not many features, but for simple and small projects its sufficient.

In Betracht gezogene Alternativen

Gründe für den Wechsel zu GitHub

Vorteile

Github has a ton of features. I've previously used SVN and Github is miles ahead of SVN as far as features. SVN has long been touted as "simpler" but it's actually very easy to have a simple workflow with Github as well but if you need more features you can get them. If you think of something you need you can google it and it probably already exists on Github.

Nachteile

Anything past a basic setup can take a very long time to learn. I've been using it for years and years and I'm still always having to learn new things about it.

Vorteile

I love how easy it is to keep ensure I have version control of my codebase, and how it hooks up with 3rd party services to make it easy to link tasks with PRs.

Nachteile

For non-hardcore developers like myself it can be challenging to setup sometimes, but it's a small downside compared to the benefits.

Vorteile

Simple, easy to understand, good to go tool for any project you are working on. The repository are available on a public and private basis. People come together to collaborate to any project

Nachteile

There are merge conflicts happening sometimes, bit tedious at that point. Also the command line interface could have been better

Vorteile

This is basically the default Git hosting for software engineering. Tooling and workflows are top notch, and generally well supported with lots of information available online.

Nachteile

Github lacks some enterprise features, and have had some security issues (the recent outage, hacks for faking repo stars).

In Betracht gezogene Alternativen

Warum GitHub gewählt wurde

Gründe für den Wechsel zu GitHub

Vorteile

Source Control is the most I like in GitHub. When we work with team, source control is important. All of team members will be pushed their codes at the same branches. If I am owner of project I will look up their code and accept their pull requests.Github's source control is easy to use to combine codes from each member. This is the one I like Github.

Nachteile

I think Authentication. I am a software developer and I use VS code as IDE.Github can authenticate with VS code. I have to GitHub account, one for personal and one for office work. When I was changed my personal to work account or vice visa, I'm faced with some issue that is git conflict among two accounts.I am worked with my office account, but in authentication, my account is still personal account. I think this part is needed to update about Github. This one is I like least about Github.

Vorteile

Almost everything is free, user interface is very easy to use/understand.
I love the community support too, a lot of developers are giving some open source products on this website

Nachteile

Some basic features like the ability to create categories to organize repositories is missing. It is a very annoying problem and a lot of people asks to implement it since many years but GitHub does not say anything about it

Vorteile

Main pros of GitHub includes collaboration, version control which tracks changes in codes and open source nature of GitHub which hosts numerous open source projects which creates a vibrant developer community

Nachteile

The primary issue for me was the learning curve when I was initially starting out as a developer and its complexity regarding managing branches, resolving conflicts and the need of constant planning and coordination in order to properly use the system and its features.

Vorteile

How it makes it more easier for developers.

Nachteile

It was hard at first understand commands, but now It’s easier.

Vorteile

I love that sense of simplicity, Github provides a lot of features that helps me organize my code versioning

Nachteile

At first i was confused about how it works, so I would like to see a simple guide at the beginning of an account

Vorteile

GitHub allows version control using Git, collaboration features to co-work with other teammates, working with open-source projects, hosting (for pages) and documentation.

Nachteile

For new starters, GitHub might be too complex due to having several features, people interested in hosting websites with GitHub pages cannot make their repositories private unless they use GitHub Pro.

In Betracht gezogene Alternativen

Gründe für den Wechsel zu GitHub

Vorteile

Github is free to use anyone can easily use to for storing their code tracking it. It's easy to use. With authentication using token only you can push your code to the github repository which provides more security. Most of the open source projects are on the github which makes it first choice for any developer.

Nachteile

As it is free to use and there is not much regularity in github which can be misused. The continuous integration & continuous deployment feature needs to be improved.

Vorteile

GitHub facilitates collaborative development by providing a platform for version control, collaboration, and code review. Multiple contributors can work on the same project simultaneously, contributing to a more efficient and organized development process.

Nachteile

GitHub heavily relies on internet connectivity. While Git itself supports offline work, certain GitHub-specific features and workflows are limited without an internet connection.

Vorteile

La gestion des versions est vraiment très utile car elle permet d'avoir un suivi sur toutes les modifications apportées. De plus, GitHub offre la collaboration en équipe sur un même projet avec le système des branches pour éviter les conflits. Le plus important est la documentation proposée qui facilite largement son utilisation.

Nachteile

Bien que GitHub est très efficace, mais il nécessite une formation initiale pour une première utilisation et être plus au moins à l'aise avec les commandes Shell. D'un autre côté, GitHub peut s'avérer très rapidement pour certaines organisations qui souhaitent avoir l'intégralité des fonctionnalités GitHub

Vorteile

It provide the free repos.
It provide more advance feature with github copilot which help in auto completing code and provider various support.
It provide merge confit feature which can solve by the portal easily.
Github Pages provide free hosting for the developer which standout this form the market.
GitHub Actions which provide continues integration and Deployment with triggers, secret config. it fill the gap between development and Deployment.
It can connect with any cloud provider tool for deployment like azure for web app, aks, function apps etc.

Nachteile

In GitHub action writing script is difficult then the other tools like yaml script.
in this script it does not provide UI to select the for pipeline.
Finding task for pipeline is very difficult.

Vorteile

It’s the most basic choice for a reason. Great, free in most cases, and provides great customization. I love github, I use it everyday, and I would recommend it over bitbucket, gitlab, etc. It provides a whole new experience. Almost like a social media VCS.

Nachteile

Honestly I don’t have any complaints to share. Github is just my favorite.

In Betracht gezogene Alternativen

Warum GitHub gewählt wurde

Zuvor genutzte Software

Gründe für den Wechsel zu GitHub

Vorteile

Cost is low, for small projects it is free.
You need version management, and this just works.
If you want more you can go deeper into actions and CI.

Nachteile

Github actions can take a bit to get setup.
If you are running CI and making lots of commits you might want to turn it off, or only turn it on for PRs.

Vorteile

- Ease-of-use
- Simple yet powerful UI
- Low price
- GitHub Student Developer Pack
- Wide Community that is eager to help
- Documentation and tons of guides
- Great support

Nachteile

- Nothing really comes to my mind, overall it's just great.

In Betracht gezogene Alternativen

Gründe für den Wechsel zu GitHub

Vorteile

Even for a non technical person, easy to navigate through the different directories for a particular repository. Easy to know where to clone or download the content.

Nachteile

Sometimes moving from branch to branch can be tricky. It's not always clear on which branch one is currently in unless we inspect the whole page. Specially on the dark theme, texts are not always properly visible.

Vorteile

Git hub provides you a platform to maintain your portfolio and your project all together. It also help in improving your CV for searching for jobs.
It helps you track your project involvement record. We can also use other persons project codes to help our projects.

Nachteile

Many a times private project are meant to be shared, and we cannot even ask to pull the code.